Invisible file remove during merge

Invisible file remove during merge

[Octavio Alvarez]

Hi.

If I do a "git rm file" during conflict resolution, the removed file
(mysterious-file.txt) does not show up on "git log --stat" nor "git show
--patch" for the merge commit.

"git log --all --stat --follow -- mysterious-file.txt" only shows the
commit where the file was added.

I also tried --full-history

I prepared a sample repository that exhibits a behavior I was not expecting:

https://github.com/alvarezp/invisible-remove-git-demo

Am I missing some option?

Thanks.

Re: Invisible file remove during merge

[Jeff King]

On Mon, Oct 10, 2016 at 06:04:26PM -0700, Octavio Alvarez wrote:

> If I do a "git rm file" during conflict resolution, the removed file
> (mysterious-file.txt) does not show up on "git log --stat" nor "git show
> --patch" for the merge commit.

"git log" does not do merge diffs by default; you need to pass one of
"--cc", "-c", or "-m".

"git show" will do "--cc" by default. Any file that is the same in the
merge result and _any_ of the branches is considered uninteresting here,
and that is what happened in your example. One parent had the file, the
other did not, and you deleted it to match the second parent.

See the "Combined Diff" section of "git help log" for more details.

When debugging merge resolutions, I often find it useful to use "-m",
which diffs separately against _each_ parent (though it is often tedious
to pick through the uninteresting bits, which is why "-c" and "--cc"
were invented in the first place).

> "git log --all --stat --follow -- mysterious-file.txt" only shows the
> commit where the file was added.

Try that with "-m", which will show the merge in question (and another,
more boring merge, which hopefully shows why "-m" is not the default).

-Peff