Re: about git hooks

[Sri Harsha Akavaram <harsha.akavaram@gmail.com>]

Awesome, thanks! for your reply

On Sun, Oct 18, 2020 at 2:08 AM brian m. carlson
<sandals@crustytoothpaste.net> wrote:
>
> On 2020-10-17 at 14:24:10, Sri Harsha Akavaramu wrote:
> > Hi git,
>
> Hey,
>
> > I just wanted to know something about git hooks.
> >
> > we use GitHub enterprise and I'm the owner of the GitHub.
> > I'm trying to understand that I want to pose the pre-commit and
> > post-commit rules on all the developers by default and is there a way
> > to pose git hook restrictions on all developers on default.
> >
> > I came to know when reading with the documentation we cant push hooks
> > to source control. Then what is the best preferred way to pose
> > pre-commit things on all developers using the repository?
>
> This is a great question, and it's kind of answered in our FAQ[0].  The
> short answer is that you don't.
>
> It's possible for any user to simply bypass pre-commit hooks with
> --no-verify without being noticed, and there are a lot of good reasons
> to do so.  For example, if I need to make a large set of changes, I may
> make a large number of temporary commits, one each time I make a change
> that works.  Those commits won't meet anybody's set of standards and
> therefore won't pass the hook, and I'll need to clean them up later, but
> that helps me organize my development process in a useful way.  The hook
> here would just be an annoyance that gets in the way.
>
> You may wish to provide hooks and an install script for the benefit of
> the user who wants them, but anything that runs on a developer system
> cannot be an effective control.
>
> The right way to add checks that need to apply to all users is to use
> either a pre-receive hook or a CI system, plus code review.  That lets
> your tooling verify things like commit message formatting, code
> formatting, tests, and other things you'll want to check before merge.
> The code review, besides being a best practice for finding bugs and
> problems before merge, also prevents developers from neutering the CI
> system by disabling it from working properly.
>
> That's the way that most organizations handle these problems, and
> generally it works pretty well.
>
> [0] https://git-scm.com/docs/gitfaq#Documentation/gitfaq.txt-HowdoIusehookstopreventusersfrommakingcertainchanges
> --
> brian m. carlson (he/him or they/them)
> Houston, Texas, US



-- 

With Regards,
SriHarsha Akavaramu,
+919493841589.