Re: [RFC/PATCH 1/2] commit: add parse_commit_repl() to replace commits at parsing time

[Junio C Hamano <gitster@pobox.com>]

Christian Couder <chriscool@tuxfamily.org> writes:

> The function parse_commit() is not safe regarding replaced commits
> because it uses the buffer of the replacement commit but the object
> part of the commit struct stay the same. Especially the sha1 is not
> changed so it doesn't match the content of the commit.

This all sounds backwards to me, if I am reading the discussion correctly.

If a replace record says commit 0123 is replaced by commit 4567 (iow, 0123
was a mistake, and pretend that its content is what is recorded in 4567),
and when we are honoring the replace records (iow, we are not fsck),
shouldn't read_sha1("0123") give us a piece of memory that stores what is
recorded in 4567, parse_object("0123") return a struct commit whose buffer
points at a block of memory that has what is recorded in 4567 _while_ its
object.sha1[] say "0123"?

What problem are you trying to solve?